Nudging vs. Scaring

Playing Outside

Originally for my nudge I had planned to encourage people at ITP to enjoy outside.  I came up with a few different nudge ideas to do this.


The first one was to get a basket and fill it with various outdoor equipment and put it near the elevators.  I originally thought this would be a nice nudge because it would give the person the idea of going outside while also some direction as to what to do without saying either. It was also a nice bonus by encouraging people to get moving too.


The second was to post a live feed of Washington Square Park to show what was currently going on outside. Unfortunately, there seems to be no live feed of Washington Square Park.  There are a few live feeds of other parks around New York but it felt too distant and almost confusing.

I then realized maybe I could use the “stick” method instead of the “carrot” to do this by posting pictures of the people bundled up in winter outfits and add a reminder that winter is coming.  This picture would show the reality of what we are going to face fairly soon and not the glorified one that shows it only after the first snow.

However, I ran into a few issues with all of these. As I was about to hit buy on Amazon for balls and other outdoor equipments, I started to think about the best days to do this.  Since it is at the beginning of the semester most people would be on the floor on Wednesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays.  This was great since it was after class but it is also the same time as the help sessions and other club meetings. After talking to a few people, I started to realize that people are just on the floor to get their work done and then go away especially on these days.

In addition, the idea of the images felt more like a push than nudge since they were pretty much telling the person to go outside.  Also, for people that haven’t been here during the winter might not understand how miserable it can get.

Ultimately, the deciding factor was quantification.  How can I quantify if people are going outside once they leave the floor? Cameras would only catch them leaving but not where they end up.  They could have taken the balls but that could have just been to take them.  It felt like there was no way to fully quantify the success of this experiment.



Because of this, I decided to switch to a more personal nudge experiment: removing eye contacts.

I have to confess that I am not the best at taking out my contacts each night. I don’t go forever without taking them out but it will be a few days.  My nightly regime was usually done before I fully finished homework or reading so I usually needed my contacts and preferred contacts over glasses.  These are the retrospective reasons I have determined for not keeping consistent.  However, I know I need to do this.  It’s something can be dangerous and cause diseases.  I decided that this was something I needed to try to do for my personal well-being.

Most importantly, this was something I can easily quantify since I would be the subject of the experiment.  At first I thought this could get in the way since I would be aware and could be biased to my actions (i.e. taking them out since I was aware) but I think because of how busy and/or groggy I get at night, it would counteract the full awareness of the experiment.

I decided I could do this by putting up a picture of diseased eyes. It helped with things like cigarettes so why not contacts. I originally thought I would put it on my phone but I decided that wouldn’t be good for two reasons: 1. I didn’t want to flood myself with the image to the point that I couldn’t even wear contacts again. 2. I didn’t want others to see the gross picture and think I’m a weirdo.

Because of these, I decided that I would put up a picture in my bathroom.  This would keep the association to the bathroom and only when I was home.  In my research for a picture, I found an article about a young woman who did not take out her contacts for six months and microscopic bugs ate her eyes to the point she went blind.  The picture attached was beyond disgusting (Warning: Picture is Repulsive.)  While the DailyMail isn’t the most accurate in news, it was useful for this experiment.

I printed the picture in black and white because my roommate would not have been pleased with the colored version. For me, even when looking at the black and white, I could still see the sickening colors.

I put the picture up on Thursday night and started the experiment.  I left it up throughout the weekend.




I can say that I was surprised about how well this worked. Not only did I take them out, I also wouldn’t wear them when I didn’t need to.

On Thursday before putting up the picture, I was already disgusted to the point that I had to take my contacts out. After that, I was diligent about taking them out as soon as I got home.  Even when I spent the night at my boyfriends, I took them out before going to bed without the need for the picture.  Every night, has been a successful one.

I don’t think I would want to keep this picture up forever. Not only is it disgusting, but it also could lose some of it’s power after awhile.  However, I think that I could use this in the future if I stop being as diligent about taking them out.

Also, I plan to do something about the nudge of encouraging people to go outside as a personal project. It’s too nice outside to miss this opportunity.



Good Interaction vs. Bad Interaction: Door Edition

We use doors every day and the way they are designed is a huge effect on us.  At some point, we have grabbed a door handle and quickly jerked it towards us as we move forward only to be met with embarrassment and feeling like a slight idiot. However, I’m in the belief that no one should feel like an idiot when grabbing the door incorrectly other than the designer.  

When a door has a handle, especially a vertical one, it is the user’s instinct to grab it and pull.  A “push” sign can help but usually this is not read until after the user has incorrectly interacted with the door and confused as to why the door isn’t working.


On example of this is the entrance door at Museum of Chinese in America (MOCA).  It’s has long vertical handles on a glass door on the right side when entering and the left side when exiting.  This is actually a good example of a good interaction and a bad interaction.  When entering, the bronze handle is easy to see, allows people of different heights to grab the handle to pull the door towards them, and because the door is glass, it allows easy visibility to whether someone is coming out.


However, on exiting, the same door is used but gives a different feeling. It has the same benefits about being long for different heights and easy to see.  This time instead of being able to pull, the user has to push.  The problem is the handle indicates a pulling motion.  The user wants to pull it and may just do that a couple times before realizing that they have to push.  It’s interesting how such a small interaction can evoke feelings of embarrassment and awkwardness.

In contrast, there are a few examples of a well designed doors.  One being a motion sensor door.  For a place like retail store, a motion sensor makes a lot of sense because it allows people easily to come in and carry out the items they may have bought.  It is especially nice for stores that have carts because the customer does not have to deal with opening the door and then dragging their cart out.

However, this is not necessarily the overall right solution. A general solution that can work is a hand plate with a sign that says “push” on one side and a handle with the a sign that says “pull” on the other.  

Another great solution is a horizontal push bar that requires the user to push on the bar which then pushes the door. This is a great solution for a door that needs to be securely closed.

Overall, I think by the awkwardness of a bad door interaction can be helped by remembering it’s not you, it’s the door.

Live Web: Live Feed Examples

I have heard of a few websites in the past that show live feeds but nevertheless, I went to trusty google to find some unusual ones.  While I found a lot of them, these three are my favorite:

1.Las Vegas Wedding Chapel

lasvegaschapel-vacuum1 from Lindsey Frances on Vimeo.

With a title like that, you expect to see some inebriated people making a big decision in their life.  However, this one got more interesting.  It instead turned into a live stream of vacuuming and lights turning on and off.

lasvegaschapel-vacuum2 from Lindsey Frances on Vimeo.

I did get excited as I saw a couple walk in but only to be disappointed to see them only looking at pamphlets later on.  However, a friend pointed out “weddings happen one after the other…but to catch vacuuming a once a day activity…that is lucky.”  What a lucky moment to catch on a live stream.


lasvegaschapel-vacuum from Lindsey Frances on Vimeo.

2. Real Life Camera NSFW!!!!


As described in the article I found on google, this is like MTV’s Real World only in a creepier way.  Apparently, couples set up a bunch of cameras showing their apartments and you can switch between couples and views.

screen-shot-2016-09-12-at-9-33-47-pmAt first, there was no moment but then as I clicked on a hallway one I was fortunate enough to see a dog playing.  This was surprisingly exciting which made me realize that live feeds are just about the moment and finding unusual things. It’s like a digital treasure hunt.


This idea was instilled even more in me when I clicked a new couple and saw a guy in his underwear playing video games as his assumed girlfriend sat naked on the couch.  To me, this was somewhat what was to be expected.  After a second, it also hit me that this was probably more of a sexual type site because who else would be watching it.  Furthermore, what type of person is paying to see inside of bedrooms of couples. I can only assume.  After this train of thought, I had to close the window. While it’s an interesting interface and works pretty well when switching (probably due to the collection of money), it’s not for me.

3. Drive Me Insane


drivemeinsane from Lindsey Frances on Vimeo.

This one is the most interactive out of the three. While watching a home office, you are givent the ability to turn on and off different lights with the hopes of “driving him insane.” It’s interesting because you can completely miss the cat in it, who doesn’t seem to care at all about what is going on.